| Year | PA | New York |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Alexa Schneider, St. Marys | Sofia Bentley, Franklinville Nevaeh Ross, Friendship-Scio Jacqueline Scanlon, Portville |
| 2023 | Evin Stauffer, Port Allegany | Madison Callen, Allegany-Limestone |
| 2022 | Julie Peterson, Ridgway | Anayah Parks-Barker, Olean |
