| 2025 |
|---|
| Caedyn Tingley (Olean) |
| Cloey Larabee (Cuba-Rushford) |
| Emma Edwards (Olean) |
| Mason Roessner (Coudersport) |
| Noah Gallo (Olean) |
| 2024 |
|---|
| Colby Nussbaum (Elk County Catholic) |
| Katelyn Rhinehart (Otto-Eldred) |
| Keelin Finn (Ellicottville) |
| Noah Shenk (Franklinville) |
| Alexa Schneider (St. Marys) |
| Jacqueline Scanlon (Portville) |
| Nevaeh Ross (Friendship) |
| Sean Conroy (Allegany-Limestone) |
| Sofia Bentley (Franklinville) |
| 2023 |
|---|
| Xander Hind (Randolph) |
| Rebecca Martin (Northern Potter) |
| Giancarlo Nuzzo (Ellicottville) |
| Katherine Sheeler (Otto-Eldred) |
| Madison Callen (Allegany-Limestone) |
| Jack DeRose (Olean) |
| Aaron Myers (Johnsonburg) |
| Evin Stauffer (Port Allegany) |
| 2022 |
|---|
| Julie Peterson (Ridgway) |
| Anayah Parks-Barker (Olean) |
| Charlie Breindel (Elk County Catholic) |
| Luke Petruzzi (Portville) |
| Kyle Mathes (Portville) |
| Sara Thomas (Olean) |
| Abigail Nuzzo (Bradford) |
| John Visnesky (CaMaraugus-LiMle Valley) |
| Elon Quigley (Salamanca) |
| Chesney Bradybaugh (Kane) |
| 2021 |
|---|
| Zazeric Bell (OMo-Eldred) |
| Kaelee Bresslin (Cameron County) |
| Mason Cool (Fillmore) |
| Jade Evens (Port Allegany) |
| Logan Frank (Franklinville) |
| Clayton Rowland (EllicoMville) |
| Sarri Swanson (Kane) |
| Jordan Pavlock (Smethport) |
| 2020 |
|---|
| Chad Greville (Kane) |
| Tyler Hind (Randolph) |
| Hannah Roeske (Fillmore) |
| Allison Schlimm (St. Marys) |
| Lindsay Steis (Ridgway) |
| Emily Wahl (Andover) |
| Karly Welty (Portville) |
| Zachery Wolfer (Franklinville) |
| 2019 |
|---|
| Adam Jones (Bolivar-Richburg) |
| Carmen Mancusa (Fillmore) |
| Meganne Chapman (EllicoMville) |
| Bryn Milne (Portville) |
| Owen Chambers (Coudersport) |
| Kamme Guisto (Cameron County) |
| Karina West (Oswayo Valley) |
| 2018 |
|---|
| Gabriela Chudy (Bolivar-Richburg) |
| Hallie Weinman (Genesee Valley) |
| Isaac Kopp (Franklinville) |
| Haley Keck (Coudersport) |
| 2017 |
|---|
| Eryn Broshar (Belfast) |
| Elsa Cole (Fillmore) |
| John Brennan (Franklinville) |
| Jenna Aldrich (EllicoMville) |
| Nicholas Grube (Kane) |
| Aaron Wilfinger (Coudersport) |
| 2016 |
|---|
| Trever Payne (Whitesville) |
| Adalia Bilotta (Cuba-Rushford) |
| Allison Forness (Allegany-Limestone) |
| Grant Miller (Portville) |
| Rachel Bauer (St. Marys) |
| Brooke Kane Walker (Smethport) |
| 2015 |
|---|
| Scott Miles (Wellsville) |
| Monroe Morris (Cuba-Rushford) |
| Geoffrey Broadbent (Olean) |
| Wesley Slugs (Randolph) |
| Alexa Marcinak (Johnsonburg) |
| Christopher Lashway (Port Allegany) |
